14. What do you think of the answers? This occurred with other words as well. —the “apple” of the Garden of Eden. Don’t be deceived. The most famous apple of Greek myth is the one you cite, the gold apple labeled “To the fairest” that Eris, goddess of discord, throws among the guests at a wedding party, leading to the judgment of Paris (he has to choose whether Hera, Aphrodite, or Athena is the most beautiful) and ultimately to the Trojan War. It was, after all, a fruit, and fruit is edible. In Italian the tomato is pomodoro, from “apple of gold,” and in French it was called “pomme d’amour,” leading to the colloquial “love apple” and the Hebrew agvania, which alludes to courtship. Many texts mentions the garden of Hesperides as somewhat similar to the garden of Eden, meaning that it is a paradise-like garden which is not accessible to ordinary mortals. 13. Keep in mind that mankind was not permitted to eat the fruit of the Tree of the Knowledge of Good and Evil, but God did not give any warning to animals. See my article entitled, “Wine from Havdalah, Women, and Beards,” Hakirah 10 (winter 2010): 175-187. Genesis doesn’t mention apples, but Proverbs 25:11 says a timely word is like apples of gold in a setting of silver. Furthermore, while apples are mentioned in Scripture (e.g., Song of Solomon 2:3, 8:5; Joel 1:12), they are not mentioned in the Garden of Eden, which is where the Tree of the Knowledge of Good and Evil was located. We and our partners will store and/or access information on your device through the use of cookies and similar technologies, to display personalised ads and content, for ad and content measurement, audience insights and product development. The midrash cited earlier that provides four suggestions for the fruit’s identity (Bereishit Rabbah 15:7) concludes with an entirely different view: “Rabbi Azariah and Rabbi Yehuda Bar Simon said in the name of Rabbi Yehoshua ben Levi ‘Heaven forbid! It says that she saw that the fruit was good for food. 10. Adam’s punishment that “by the sweat of your brow you will eat bread” (Bereishit 3:19; cf. who made these four suggestions link them to some aspect of the story. By choosing I Accept, you consent to our use of cookies and other tracking technologies. Chazal state that the Forbidden Fruit was one of following: The Gemara explains that children know how to say “Daddy” and “Mommy” only after beginning to consume grains. (fruit of knowledge). From product development to industrial 3D manufacturing, we can help you scale your business. What did fruit from the Tree of the Knowledge of Good and Evil look like? ” but called by the masses “the fig of Adam HaRishon,” because they say that it is from the leaves of that plant from which Adam and Chava made for themselves a garment. It was the fruit that came from the Tree of the Knowledge of Good and Evil. As of now, the Apple is still in the hands of the Templars. Would love your thoughts, please comment. The binomial scientific name for apple is Pyrus mālus. : DVD Set with Book, Satan, the Fall, and a Look at Good and Evil. As you suggest, the original Hebrew says only “fruit,” but in latter-day Western art ranging from serious religious painting to about a million cartoons, the item in question is invariably depicted as an apple. And he correctly notes that the sabra is as an American species, implying that it is unlikely to have been in Gan Eden. white nylon plastic polished to reveal a smooth matte finish. The Gra says that the berachah took place on Rosh Hashanah and this midrash is one of the reasons for the custom of dipping specifically an apple in honey (Gra, OC 583). Furthermore, they assume that although the Torah did not identify the Tree, it provided clues through which the careful reader can deduce its identity. However, there is another Latin noun mālum (pronounced may-lum) meaning apple, which was borrowed from Greek.11 In light of the similarity of the words, and due to the fact that in Europe the cold-weather apple was very popular, it is easy to see how people began to identify the Tree as an apple tree. What’s the difference between Sunni and Shi’ite Muslims? Eventually, interbreeding between humanity and the First Civilization led to the creation of a hybrid race, which was immune to the hypnotic effects of the Pieces of Eden. In 1277 Nathan HaMe’ati translated the Rambam’s medical work, ) from Arabic into Hebrew. 15:7) concludes with an entirely different view: “Rabbi Azariah and Rabbi Yehuda Bar Simon said in the name of Rabbi Yehoshua ben Levi ‘Heaven forbid! Indeed, wine has contradictory characteristics. But it wasn’t always. A related question: what’s meant by the “knowledge of good and evil”? Commenting on this, Rashi quotes a midrash that says that the scent Yitzchak detected was that of the Garden of Eden; in a separate comment, the Talmud (Taanit 29b), again quoted by Rashi, says the field referred to is a “tapuach”orchard.18  If one understands the Biblical tapuach to mean an apple, then based on these sources one can conclude that the Tree was an apple tree. Forbidden fruit is a name given to the fruit growing in the Garden of Eden which God commands mankind not to eat. At some point, two individuals, Adam and Eve, stole one of the Pieces – the Apple of Eden – from their masters. The other Sages seemingly did not agree with Rabbi Azariah and Rabbi Yehudah Bar Simon, as they did not hesitate to try to discover the identity (although their discussions may have been more about drawing out various ethical lessons than verifying the Tree’s actual identity). Ethical discrimination, knowing right from wrong. In older art, the Forbidden Fruit is often a non-descript fruit. An Adam’s apple, the laryngeal prominence on the human neck (mostly found on males) is named either because it looks as if a piece of the apple got lodged there or, more likely, because it is a round bulge. The Targum translates tapuach as etrog (Shir Hashirim 2:3) and as tapuah deginta dieden—the apple of the Garden of Eden (ibid., 2:5, 7:9). Rabbi Raisher describes the sabra as having a thick skin that is full of thin needles and flesh that tastes as sweet as honey. The phrase “apple of my eye” derives from the fact that the pupil was thought to be a round object and was called an apple. in Latin) were words that denoted a generic fruit or a round object. Fook COVID vaccine! Early Christian scholars often took the forbidden fruit to be an apple, possibly because of the irresistible pun suggested by the Latin malum, which means both “apple” and “evil.” At least one early Latin translation of the bible uses “apple” instead of “fruit.” A contributing factor no doubt was that apples were a lot more popular in Europe than in the Middle East, where it’s generally too hot for them to thrive.